Drafting Written
Policies
Regardless of content or context, there are several things
to keep in mind when drafting written policies governing CI operations:
-
They should be drafted in cooperation with the legal
department.
-
They should be simple and direct.
-
They should provide guidance, and not merely tell people to
contact someone.
-
They should reflect your unique situation and competitive
environment.
Draft in cooperation with the Legal
Department. As noted, there are no significant legal issues surrounding the
normal conduct of CI for a business. In spite of that, those preparing these
policies should make sure that the members of the CI unit work closely with
members of a legal team in drafting them.
There are several reasons for this. First, the process of drafting
the policies and reviewing applicable laws helps overcome any latent prejudice
within a legal team that CI is synonymous with, or at least dangerously close
to, industrial espionage. Second, by being involved in drafting, the members of
the legal team become more educated on how CI actually functions. This better
prepares them to respond quickly to any questions or concerns raised by the CI
staff once the policies are in place. Third, it can help bring any legal team
into the CI unit's internal networking. This can be strengthened by having the
legal department become involved in training both CI staff and other employees
on the real legal and ethical issues involved with CI.
Simple and Direct. To be most useful, the
policy must be understandable. Telling employees that they cannot
"misappropriate a trade secret" may be easy to draft, but provides very little
guidance. Telling employees that they are "not permitted to try to get trade
secrets" and that "if a trade secret comes into your possession, no matter how
that happens," they must take specified actions is much more useful.
Provide positive guidance. A corollary to
the previous statement is that a policy should not only tell people what not to
do, it should also tell them what to do. While there are times when you want a
policy to say everyone should "stop and contact" a specified person, always keep
in mind that you should be educating employees as to the proper type of conduct
they should take, without guidance, in the vast majority of foreseeable cases.
If you tell employees to contact someone rather than giving them positive
guidance, then do not be surprised if the specified contacts are made again and
again.
Reflect your unique situation and competitive
environment. Finally, try to develop policies that reflect your own, unique
corporate culture and competitive environment. In fact, going through that very
process will serve to educate both the CI staff and the legal team on the real
problems that will be faced. That, in turn, will improve both the final product
and the level of future compliance.